Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Eyeliner, Satin Finish, Waterproof Formula, Pitch Black, 0.018 Fl Oz

Easily the best pen liner I've ever used. Been using this since 2017 thereabouts and I never have a reason to complain. Goes on smooth, true black, precise tip, mainly waterproof and smudge free but comes off easily with a makeup remover. I sometimes use it on my inner lash line and it never gets messy and run into my eyes. The first one I had years ago, I was carless and the tip got bent when I was placing the cap back on, and it never quite straightened back out, but that's user error, so use with care.

The best eye liner by far. Easy to apply and stays all day. Just make sure the cap actually snaps on it it's popping off and your drying out asap. It's the only one that doesn't irritate my eyes. It's bold and bright and doesn't smear or flake off and the tip is helpful in making fine lines and doesn't drag on the skin

Love this eye liner! It goes on smoothly and stays in place when my eyes water…the only draw back is that it has to dry first other wise it runs/smears in the inner corners of my eye. As I’ve gotten older my eye water easily for no reason and I have to put this on when they are dry but it stays and lasts till I wash it off at night!

This liner is pretty excellent for the price. I used to use Kat Von D, but I ain't got that money anymore. Even if I did, I'd keep using this over the fancier brands. In humid Florida it holds well if you use something to set your eyelids first. Which means if you live somewhere dry? You are set my friend. My eye area tends to get sweaty, and maybe by the end of a 6-8 hour day in humid summer it'll start smudging a teensy bit. By then I'm generally at home. It can be difficult to remove---I use oil to massage it off my skin, and then soap my face. And even then I might still have some residue that a face tonic easily rids of. Worth the work for how good it lasts. Easy to draw, the color is DARK and you only really need one layer. It's comfy and glides on well and doesn't bleed. I have hooded eyes so I have to keep my eyes closed for it to dry first, as with all liquid liner. Only downside? The brush tip bleeds a bit. Like, it bubbles out the product and I have to clear it off with a napkin. Otherwise, the felt tip is soooo saturated that my lines get smudged or it'll apply too much product. I've had it for a while now, and so perhaps being tossed around in my purse has made it sad. It hasn't exploded though and still works rather well. I feel I've used it so much and it doesn't seem to plan on drying anytime soon.

I didn't care for this at all. The tip is a brush it's not great for application. Seemed to come off easily and dried out on me quickly. Wouldn't buy again. Any suggestions for a no smudge long lasting liner?

This eyeliner is okay, but I'm not a big fan of the brush tip. It frayed out pretty quickly, and I wasn't a big fan of how the product came off the brush at first compared to my others. It definitely was not my favorite tip but i got used to it . If you don't have a lot of experience, then this is not the tip for you. I did okay with it, but in the morning, I'm tired and don't always feel ad steady, and it's made a mess of your not careful, and it does smear and flow out! The good thing about this eyeliner is that it does flow off easily w little effort and has a shaker ball to stir it. It goes a long way and didn't dry out like some, so if it weren't for the brush issues, I would have gotten months more! I use my eyeliner every day, maybe skipping a day here and there, but I had this all summer and then kinda kept pulling the loose frayed to make it last longer through fall, till i got sick.of it and opened the next one discarding all the eyelin lift in the tube . It is very black, also, which is good and what i like. The brush is fine, and before it frayed, it was nice for detailing the fine line I do. I got two, so I'm hoping the second will be a better experience with the fraying of the brush because if it weren't for that, I would give it four stars! This time I'm a lot more careful with how I lay it and close it. I Make sure you lay it up because the product will flow down and make a mess because of how liquidy thin the liner is!

I’ve tried many liquid eyeliners over the years, and this one immediately impressed me with its precision, smooth application, and long-lasting formula. The fine felt-tip pen makes it easy to create clean lines, whether I want a subtle everyday look or a bold, dramatic wing. The no-skip formula is a game-changer. It glides on evenly without dragging or smudging, which is often a problem with other liquid liners. The satin finish provides a polished, professional look without being overly shiny or matte. Plus, the pitch-black color is rich and intense, delivering true pigment in just one swipe. Another standout feature is the waterproof formula. It stays put through workouts, long days, and even light rain without smudging or fading. Yet, it removes easily with my regular makeup remover, so I don’t have to tug at my delicate eye area. Durability, precision, and ease-of-use all come together perfectly in this liner. For anyone who wants reliable, high-quality eyeliner that makes application effortless, this is an excellent choice. I’ll definitely be keeping it in my everyday makeup routine as it’s precise, bold, and never disappoints. Great texture and value for money!

I love the MAYBELLINE New York Hyper Easy Liquid liner. The brush tip makes it really easy to get a clean, precise line even when I’m in a hurry. It goes on smoothly, stays put all day, and doesn’t smudge on me. I’ve tried a lot of liners, and this one is one of the easiest to use. Definitely a 5-star product for my daily makeup routine.