SEPHORA COLLECTION Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner #10 Matte Brown Black

Easy to put on, waterproof, little to no smudging (unless you rub your eyes).

It's a great eyeliner, but it's only $14 at Sephora.

This is the best eyeliner I have ever used. It is certainly worth the extra $$. Other pencils faded off or smeared, but this one stays put and stays dark. I do not like the "ink" on eyeliner and like the "pencil" look (it looks more dramatic and not "drawn on"), so this is perfect. Since eyeliner is the only makeup I wear most of the time, it is worth it to get a good brand, and this is it! -Tania

Usually I use pencil and just soften it with a lighter because most eyeliners smudge and run so I was happy that I didn't have to use the lighter and it didn't run or smudge. 12 hours after applying and still looks great. Went on smooth and easy this will be my new favorite

Nice

I heard about this on a Makeup video on You tube. I love it. It goes on so nice and does not smudge. Perfect for traveling as the tops stay on and it gives a perfect line all the time.

The color and precision of this pencil was what I wanted. A muted dark pencil for under eye and at base of lids. It did however come apart with the pencil lead and base falling out and landing in pieces in the sink. I put it back together and can hold it together to continue to use it. It is just not expected as a Sephora product.

I'm 69, and I've never had an eyeliner I've been 100% satisfied with in my entire life...until this one. It goes on easily, the tip stays well-shaped, it can be smudged with the special tip if one does it immediately after applying, and even in 100-degree heat, the makeup stays neatly in place. I have very sensitive skin and eyes, and this product does not bother me at all. I don't like paying a high price, but it is the best I've ever tried.