MALLOMARS Pure Chocolate Cookies, 8.2 oz

I was hoping that these cookies would be the same as the chocolat "finger" cookies I liked when I was young. They are similar enough in taste that I will buy them again. I'm on my third one now. Can't eat just one. I'm going to send some to friends. Updated review. I ordered 4 more boxes. Three for myself and one for my son. His arrived in good condition. I opened my 1st box tonight. Yikes, very dissapointed. Returning tomorrow. I imagine that it is not Amazon's fault. I mean how would Amazon know when these cookies are bad? I'll still give 5 stars because the return process is painless and they are delicious if they are edible when they arrive. However, I'm reluctant to reorder, but I may order a single box because thery are not available in stores near me. ..... Yes I have to order a single box. Update 10/31/25 . I placed an order for a single box of these cookies. I was notified that I reached my order limit and could not order more. I was unaware that some Amazon products have order limits. Bummer. 2nd Update.Well, these cookies are so good that I took a chanch and ordered another single box. Upon opening this bow, I found that some of the bottoms seperated from the marshmello top. (no pictire) These cookies are quite delicate. I believe that when they were delivered, the carton was dropped on my doorstep as is usually done by shipping companies.But, they were certainly edible. So I just held the pieces together when I ate them. Mmmm, delicious. I will definately order them again. I have no idea what happened to the cookies seen in the photo I provided. Might have been warehoused improperly. ??? I am soo glad that I gave them another try. Definately five star if you overlook the bad ones I received.

I am a native New Yorker and have been eating Mallomars my whole life and these are the best I ever had! Very, very fresh and delicious.

These Mallomars are so fresh tasting. If you never tried them before, try them now!

These were a disgrace - the single worse edible product I have ever purchased on Amazon! I (and my friends) look forward every fall to enjoying Mallomars again. What I received was three boxes of stale, tasteless cookies which all wound up in the garbage disposal. There was not one cookie that was whole - the bottoms had separated from each item. The taste reminded me of something that had either been sitting on a shelf in a warehouse for years or had been exposed to extreme heat. Please don't try to blame this on shipping. The cookie boxes had been carefully and safely packed by Amazon shipping personnel. The fault lies entirely in the product itself. PLEASE don't waste your money (or your taste buds) on items from this source.

This is legendarily delicious. Yes, depending on storage at Amazon and during transport, you may see sugar or fat bloom. Personally, as long as the seller is Amazon themselves, it's never been so terrible that it wasn't still delicious.

These were very good. I was worried because the best by date was back in March. I hope they stay fresh for at least 2 weeks.

5 stars for freshness and excellent appearance. All cookies are intact and look good. Marshmallow is fresh, graham bottom is fresh, outer chocolate is fresh. Ships fine. I wish the outer chocolate was more of a true milk chocolate. This has a dark chocolate taste. Not bad, just my preference is milk chocolate. Nice clean treat, doesnt make a mess. Not so sweet that it is cloying.

No idea why they don't stock them locally. Guess they want use to buy from Amazon.