Legacy Liquid Eye Liner – Ultra-Black, Quick-Drying, All-Day Wear – Flexible Felt Tip for Precision – Satin Finish

This is a really good eyeliner. It's really good quality it's very easy to apply. It has good glide and it has lasted me a long time. I have not noticed any smudging and I love how black it is. I would definitely recommend this.

If you’re looking for a thick dark black this isn’t for you

the ink was a bit blotty and was not really coming not smoothly

I really like this eyeliner. It goes on smoothly, it’s very precise, looks great, and lasts a long time without smudging. The liquid eyeliner is a rich, deep black. It has no odor. Before use, you have to shake the pen to make sure the liquid in the barrel is mixed well. I have some other liquid eyeliner that doesn’t have this feature, and I was surprised to see it in this one. I also love the smooth, metallic look of the barrel and cap, which looks great left out on the counter. Upon first use, this did not fail. I could make both thin and thick solid black lines easily. The very fine tip is very useful. I could smudge the outer ends of the lines on my lashes just a little if I did it right away while it was still wet. After it dried, it did not smudge at all. It’s also waterproof. I used some cream makeup remover to remove it. It did take a little rubbing for it to come off fully, but that is just a testament to how well it stays on. I also love that this contains bamboo charcoal, which they say is know to absorb skin toxins and impurities. It doesn’t contain a list of ingredient paragraphs long. It’s cruelty free too. These things make me feel better about using it.

Not sure if I got a defective piece but the color was so light you could barely see it. All water

In the past I've put eyeliner on using a very narrow brush and dark/black eyeshadow - because pencils and gels don't flow smoothly enough for me to tolerate the pressure needed to use them. This product is a liquid marker style and I have none of those issues. It is free flowing, but only where it touches your skin (or any other surface). No pressure is needed. It tapers to a very fine point and can draw extremely narrow lines as a result. The ingredient list is reasonably short for a cosmetic, with the first two ingredients being water and charcoal powder. It can initially be smeared/smudged, but dries within about a minute and then only is easily removed with make-up wipes or similar methods. This is my new go-to and with how firmly it clicks shut to seal out air, I'm hopeful it will last a long time!

I mostly only wear black eyeliner and prefer liquid liners such as this one, and I like the application and the immediate depth of color. This eyeliner doesn't skip or feather when applying, and it gives a solid and deeply black line with one swipe. The line is on the thicker side and I have a bit of trouble getting a fine line with this liner, but if I want a thicker line this one delivers. This liner is quick to dry, and it's easy to correct before it dries. It looks great on for about three hours, but after four or five hours it starts wearing off. Also I was able remove this eyeliner with a warm and damp washcloth somewhat easily so it's not exactly waterproof, and it comes off much more easily with oil based removers. This liner doesn't cause my eyes any irritations, as it wears off it doesn't flake and darken the area under my eyes, and it doesn't smudge during wear. Overall this is a nice but somewhat short-lived eyeliner and I'm reasonably satisfied with it, but I feel that the current price of 22 USD is a bit high for it. Live Tinted Legacy Liquid Eye Liner – Ultra-Black, Quick-Drying, All-Day Wear – Flexible Felt Tip for Precision – Satin Finish

Made in Japan. No expiration date or safety seal. I don't usually use liquid liners like this because I'm not very good with them but this one may change my mind. Very easy to get close to lash line with a thin line. Doesn't budge once it dries and it dries quickly. Removed easily with my usual eye makeup remover. Not cheap but it exceeded my expectations and I'd actually get this again at the current price so five stars from me.