Neutrogena Healthy Volume Lash-Plumping Mascara, Volumizing and Conditioning Mascara with Olive Oil to Build Fuller Lashes, Clump-, Smudge- and Flake-Free, Black 02, 0.21 oz (Pack of 2)

I have used this mascara for years. It does not irritate my eyes and goes on well without clumping. While not entirely tearproof, it is smudgeproof and it is preferable to use makeup remover to take it off. I've used both soft black and brown-black with good results.

I love this ! It doesn’t clump and goes on easily.

This mascara is ok...It as no smell,goes on ok..Seem kind of dry.But didn't care for the feel of the formula. Did not make lashes appear longer..Was looking for the most natural formula..IT was very hard to remove.Is Waterproof! Must use mascara remover..Which I ordered also same Company.... But was very hard to remove. And was afraid to wipe to hard..Will say was great price. As you received 2 for one price... It was Reviewed # 1 of 5 Best Mascara for sensitive eyes...did not bother my eyes.. Just removable was my issue... No flaking, some clumping.. Would not buy again...

This is the only mascara that doesn’t bug my eyes. It has a great all day hold, but isn’t clumpy or hard to get off. I’ve tried some others but they would make my eyes water and a few made my lashes harder to clean. I don’t feel like my lashes are particularly long but this helps them look long but natural.

I have purchased this product in several ways, by store and by Amazon and each and every time it is dry and last about two applications. I have bought it throughout the years when I’ve had no other option and it just never seems to matter when or where I buy it; it’s the same result. It truly is the worst.

Right out of the tube there were flakes ... Took 2 coats to even see a difference... Not worth the $ IMO .. Returning... ☹️

I have very sensitive eyes. Actually they are also very dry. I used to use any type of mascara. While visiting my bf in New Zealand I thought I developed allergies becuz my eyes were itchy and very dry feeling. I couldn't wait to take off my mascara. Always felt like I had grit in them. Started taking allergy pills. I would change my tube of mascara every month also. Searched Google and cane to the conclusion IT WAS THE MASCARA plus combination of super dry eyes. Searched again for a mascara that would help me with dry eyes. Many told me "stop using mascara". Yeah sure I'll get right on that...NOT. This mascara was rated #1. Thought I'd give it a try. Tried other ones so why not? I've been using this GREAT mascara for 2 weeks now. No itching No gritty feeling No need to rush to take it off No clumping The wand where the mascara of gathered is super long. Holds a lot of the product. Actually I refill it with the product maybe 2xs when putting it on. (If you don't want ANY mascara to clump you need to "comb" thru your lashes after you apply any product). GREAT mascara So good I subscribe and save.

I’ve never written a review here on Amazon before, but I felt compelled to come back and report that this mascara is your lashes a bit better. Literally this just looks like my natural lashes. No clumping, no smudging and after a complete work day that started early this morning and ended nine hours later. I’m still completely flake free. Zero flakes. Super pleased.

Easily the most un-messy to apply mascara. The brush allows one not to put too much on. Doesn’t clump.

I love this mascara as it non-irritating to my eyes. Love the formula as there are no fibres. It increases the volume although looks natural and was recommended online and is true as stated.

Excelente, es la primera máscara que no se me corre

Only 1 arrived. Definitely not a pack of 2!

sad but it is Dry and empty..