L’Oréal Paris L'Oreal Clean Artiste Eye Makeup Remover, 4.0 Ounces

I received this product as a replacement for Neutrogena Eye Makeup Remover since Amazon has a real problem of keeping various products in stock lately, it was recommended by Amazon as a like-product so I figured it would be comparable. NOT!! This solution DOES NOT remove mascara or eyeliner or brow liner. At best it removed the powder and base on my eyes, and that was only after intense scrubbing (my poor eyes). The bottle wasn't even sealed so for all I know someone stole the solution and replaced it with water. I'll never buy this again. It's useless.

Took a few swipes to remove eye makeup. Most removers will take off long wearing lip color but this one doesn’t.

I ran out of Mabelline so I tried this one. No complaints. Might be A bit more expensive.

I switched to this from an oilier version. This doesn’t irritate my eyes AT ALL and gets the waterproof mascara off. I’m old and mascara is about the only makeup I use. I’ll keep using this. Great stuff.

LOVE this stuff, have used it for many, many years. Have friends who've become addicted to it as well. Eye makeup comes off cleanly and even if I'm not particularly careful it doesn't seem to sting my eyes. Not oily, not drying...kind of ridiculously priced for what it is probably but I still buy it religiously and sometimes two at a time because it's always sold out or very nearly in the stores. Apparently the secret is out.