COLORGRAM Shade Re-Forming Brush Liner 04 Pink | Silky-Smooth Soft Long-Lasting Eyeliner, Point Eye Makeup, Smudgeproof, All Day Wear Party Makeup

My favorite eyeliner. It gives a natural look and is easy to use (I’m usually really bad at liquid eyeliner).

very pretty color but very hard, needs to warm up against by rubbing against hand or something

Bought it for my mom. I think this is the one that was a little reddish instead of a neutral medium brown. The texture of the pencil was alright, seemed to work well for her apart from the color.

Works good, just cannot last very long. If work out or sweating a lot, better add one layer use eyebrow raincoat.

I saw that this came recommended from Pony, the Youtube makeup artist, and was on the hunt for a brown eyeliner that wasn't so dark. OMG. As someone with oily eyelids who can't even manage to make eyeshadow last for more than an hour, this thing doesn't budge. It's truly a cream liner as even whilst swatching it glided on smoothly on the back of my skin. But it barely took a few seconds to set and as I tried to wipe it off with my hands, a wet wipe, and tissue, it wouldn't move unless I used an oil cleanser. Do get this and try it.

Been looking for a cool toned brown eyeliner. Found this one. Opened it up and tried to test on hand. No color. Not even faint. Pressed a little harder and got a gritty line. Figured now it should be good. Had to press harder and the tip begin falling off. Line had chunks of liner. Not smooth Not consistent and does not smudge. Do not recommend. 4 out of the last 6 purchases from Amazon I've had to return due to quality control in the last month.

I purchased this after seeing a girl use it on TikTok but I was honestly a little disappointed. When I first purchased it, it applied really nicely but I noticed that it smudged under my eyes when I used it for my aegyosal. I’m not sure if I’m prepping incorrectly but I’ve even tried powdering under my eyes but even then, it smudges throughout the day. I feel like I get better wear when I use eyeshadow. I’m still giving 3 stars because it is a very convenient product and it comes in a variety of ferment shades and undertones to suit anyone’s makeup needs

But it sure could be your brow filler! Somehow matches my hair almost exactly and goes on easily and doesn't smudge at all. I've had no issues about it drying out on me and I will 100% buy it again as soon as I'm running out!